How do you make feedback an everyday rhythm?

In this article, you'll learn to avoid the pitfalls of either being too harsh or too lenient by using Radical Candor to give honest feedback that both challenges and supports your team.

You’ll learn:

  • The core principles of Radical Candor and how it balances care and directness.

  • Why leaders often fall into the trap of either ruinous empathy or obnoxious aggression.

  • Practical steps to give feedback that strengthens relationships and drives performance.

Feedback is a weakness for most teams.

Giving feedback is one of the most important yet difficult responsibilities for any leader. Striking the right balance between supporting your team and challenging them to grow can be tricky. Too often, leaders err on one side of the spectrum or the other: either they are too nice and avoid difficult conversations to spare feelings (ruinous empathy), or they are too blunt and direct, delivering feedback in a way that feels harsh or demotivating (obnoxious aggression).

In both cases, the result is the same—team members are left confused, unmotivated, or unsure of how to improve. If you're too empathetic, your team may feel coddled and avoid accountability. If you're too aggressive, your team may feel disrespected, leading to resentment and disengagement.

The solution to this challenge lies in Radical Candor, a framework developed by Kim Scott. Radical Candor encourages leaders to give feedback that cares personally while challenging directly, creating a balanced approach that fosters both personal growth and professional performance.

Busy? Watch the 3-minute micro-lecture.

Discover a simple mindset to help you and your team deliver more valuable, direct feedback.

Understanding Radical Candor

Radical Candor is built on two key dimensions:

  1. Care Personally: This means building genuine relationships with your team members and showing that you care about them not just as employees, but as human beings. Leaders who care personally invest in their team’s well-being and are committed to helping them grow.

  2. Challenge Directly: This involves being willing to give direct, honest feedback that pushes your team members to improve. It’s about telling the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable, but doing so in a way that is helpful rather than hurtful.

Radical Candor is about balancing these two elements—care and challenge—to create a feedback dynamic that drives improvement without sacrificing trust or respect.

The Four Quadrants of Radical Candor

To fully understand Radical Candor, it’s helpful to explore the four quadrants that arise when leaders balance (or fail to balance) care and challenge:

  1. Radical Candor: This is the sweet spot, where you care personally about your team members and challenge them directly. This leads to open, honest communication and mutual trust.

  2. Ruinous Empathy: This occurs when you care personally but fail to challenge directly. You avoid tough conversations to spare someone’s feelings, which leads to unclear expectations, missed opportunities for growth, and poor performance.

  3. Obnoxious Aggression: This happens when you challenge directly but fail to show personal care. You give blunt, harsh feedback without considering the person’s feelings, leading to resentment and disengagement.

  4. Manipulative Insincerity: This is the worst of both worlds—when you neither care personally nor challenge directly. Feedback is either avoided or delivered with hidden motives, resulting in a lack of trust and low morale.

The Pitfalls of Ruinous Empathy and Obnoxious Aggression

While most leaders understand the need to give feedback, many fall into the trap of ruinous empathy or obnoxious aggression—often without even realizing it. Here’s how each pitfall plays out:

Ruinous Empathy:

Leaders who are overly empathetic may avoid giving tough feedback because they don’t want to hurt someone’s feelings. They may sidestep difficult conversations or soften their words so much that the message gets lost.

While this may feel kind in the moment, it ultimately leads to confusion and stagnation. Team members may not even realize that they’re underperforming or missing the mark. Without honest feedback, they can’t improve, which frustrates both the leader and the team.

Example: A manager consistently overlooks a team member’s missed deadlines, hoping that things will improve without confrontation. Over time, the entire team becomes frustrated with the delays, and the underperforming employee feels demoralized because they’re never given clear feedback on how to improve.

Obnoxious Aggression:

On the other end of the spectrum, leaders who are too direct may give feedback in a way that feels harsh or critical. While the feedback may be accurate, the delivery lacks empathy and consideration, which can damage relationships and erode trust.

In these cases, team members may feel disrespected or undervalued, leading to disengagement. Instead of feeling motivated to improve, they may resent the feedback and resist change.

Example: A manager publicly criticizes an employee in a meeting for making a mistake, with little regard for how the employee might feel. While the feedback is valid, the delivery is so harsh that the employee feels embarrassed and demoralized, making it harder for them to focus on improvement.

How to Practice Radical Candor

Implementing Radical Candor in your leadership approach means developing the skill to both care personally and challenge directly in your interactions with your team. Here’s a step-by-step guide to practicing Radical Candor effectively:

1. Build Strong Relationships First

Radical Candor starts with building trust and rapport. Your team needs to know that you genuinely care about them as individuals. This doesn’t mean being overly familiar or becoming best friends with your employees—it’s about showing that you respect them, value their contributions, and are invested in their success.

Actionable Tip: Take time to get to know your team members on a personal level. Ask about their goals, interests, and challenges. Show empathy in everyday conversations and offer support when they need it.

2. Be Direct and Clear with Feedback

When it comes to challenging directly, clarity is key. Don’t beat around the bush or sugarcoat feedback to the point that it becomes unclear. If someone is underperforming or making mistakes, they need to know about it in order to improve.

However, being direct doesn’t mean being harsh. Focus on facts and outcomes rather than personal judgments. Frame your feedback in a way that is constructive and solution-oriented.

Actionable Tip: When giving feedback, use the SBI model (Situation, Behavior, Impact):

  • Situation: Describe the context in which the behavior occurred.

  • Behavior: Explain the specific behavior that you observed.

  • Impact: Highlight the impact the behavior had on the team or project.

For example, instead of saying, “You’re not reliable,” say, “In yesterday’s meeting (situation), you missed the deadline for submitting the report (behavior), which delayed the team’s progress on the project (impact).”

3. Provide Feedback in a Private, Supportive Setting

One of the principles of Radical Candor is to give feedback in a way that respects the person’s dignity. Criticizing someone in public can feel like a personal attack and may cause unnecessary embarrassment.

Instead, give feedback privately, where the person can absorb the information without feeling exposed or defensive. Ensure that your tone is supportive, and frame the conversation as an opportunity for growth.

Actionable Tip: After giving feedback, ask open-ended questions to engage the employee in the process. For example, ask, “What do you think about the feedback?” or “How can I support you in making these improvements?”

4. Embrace Feedback in Return

Radical Candor isn’t a one-way street. As a leader, you should also be open to receiving feedback from your team. Encouraging upward feedback creates a culture of mutual trust and shows your team that you value their input.

When receiving feedback, resist the urge to become defensive. Instead, thank the person for their honesty and reflect on how you can use their feedback to improve your leadership.

Actionable Tip: Regularly ask your team for feedback on your leadership style. For example, you might ask, “Is there anything I could be doing better to support you?” This opens the door for honest conversations and continuous improvement.

5. Be Consistent in Your Approach

Radical Candor only works if it’s practiced consistently. Make feedback an ongoing part of your leadership practice, rather than something that only happens during formal reviews. Regular, open communication builds trust and ensures that team members always know where they stand.

Benefits of Radical Candor

When implemented correctly, Radical Candor has several powerful benefits for both leaders and teams:

1. Improved Team Performance

By challenging directly, you give your team the feedback they need to grow and improve. When expectations are clear, and feedback is constructive, team members can address issues quickly and perform at a higher level.

2. Stronger Relationships

Caring personally means that you’re invested in your team’s success, not just in their output. This fosters deeper trust and stronger relationships, which ultimately leads to higher levels of engagement and loyalty.

3. A Culture of Openness and Trust

When feedback is given openly and honestly, it creates a culture of transparency. Team members are more likely to speak up, share ideas, and collaborate when they know that feedback is rooted in mutual respect and a desire to improve.

How you can start applying these ideas

Here are some practical tips and reflective questions to help you apply Radical Candor in your leadership:

1. Build Trust Before Giving Tough Feedback:

  • Advice: Make sure your team knows you care about them as individuals before you start delivering tough feedback. Building trust is the foundation for Radical Candor.

  • Thought Starter: How can I show my team that I care about their well-being and success on a daily basis?

2. Be Clear, Not Harsh:

  • Advice: Don’t soften your feedback to the point of confusion, but make sure it’s delivered in a respectful and supportive way.

  • Thought Starter: How can I deliver clear feedback that focuses on behaviors and outcomes rather than personal judgments?

3. Encourage Two-Way Feedback:

  • Advice: Make feedback a two-way conversation by regularly asking your team for input on your own leadership.

  • Thought Starter: How can I create a culture where feedback flows both ways, and everyone feels safe to speak openly?

Wrap-up: challenge people directly with their best interests at heart to make feedback in-demand.

Radical Candor is a powerful leadership tool that helps you balance personal care with direct feedback, creating a dynamic where your team can thrive. By caring personally and challenging directly, you build stronger relationships, foster open communication, and drive higher levels of performance.

If you want your team to grow, learn, and succeed, it’s time to embrace Radical Candor in your leadership approach.

CHANGE BY SPRINT VALLEY

Ready for change?

Fast-track ambitious ideas and build a future-ready business your people are proud to be a part of.

SEE HOW IT WORKS